I’m in Heaven…

My quest for pizza perfection is no secret.  Tonight was a giant leap toward that goal.  I’m going to apologize now, this is a long one.  I mentioned awhile back having checked out Peter Reinhart’s American Pie and his quest for the perfect pizza.

My perfect pizza is a super thin crispy crust with a extra browned (pre-char) pizza topping.  While I love pizza on the grill for the great crust, the cheese doesn’t brown on top.

I have made Peter’s Roman Pizza Dough a few times now and this is my new favorite dough.  I haven’t done it on the grill yet.  It is VERY thin, the grill will be a good test.  So far I have only been doing this in the oven as he has suggested.  Peter suggests starting with your stone in the middle, then move to lower racks if needed to get the crispier crust.  I got the best results with it on the bottom rack.  Preheat the oven at your oven’s highest temperature, fluctuating to broil now and then to get it even hotter.  When my oven was at full 550* preheated, I turned to broil for 5-10 minutes, then turned back down to 550 when I put the pizza in.

The Recipe:
5 cups(22 1/2oz) all-purpose flour **
1/4 cup (1oz) semolina flour
3 teaspoons kosher salt
1 teaspoon instant yeast (my teaspoon was generous)
1 3/4 cups cool water
Divide this into six 6-ounce dough balls.

He gives detailed instruction on how to knead and rest and knead again. But if you haven’t figured out by now, I’m lazy. I love the mix, sorta knead and walk away method. I brought the dough together and gave it a few good turns then covered with a damp towel and went for my morning walk. An hour(ish) later, I gave it a few more good turns, drizzled with some olive oil and tucked in to rest in the hint o’ warm oven for the day.

That night, I kinda rushed it and was sorely disappointed in my results. Be assured there wasn’t a crumb left and everyone seemed pretty happy, but it wasn’t right. I threw 3 dough balls in zip-top bags and threw them in the freezer.

Fast forward 6 days. I pulled a dough bag out of the freezer this morning when I left for work and left it on the counter. When I got home I turned the oven to 550 and turned the dough out of the bag onto a lightly floured counter gently turning it into a ball (trying not to break all my bubbles). I dinked around for a few minutes, then fired up my cast iron skillet and threw in chopped onion and eggplant, spinkled with some kosher salt and cumin.

I rolled the dough out then let it rest a few minutes before I rolled it all the way out.  Dusting my peel with a little flour making sure my dough moved smoothly, I began building.  I hadn’t thawed any sauce so I just took a few tablespoons of tomato paste and smeared a thin layer on the dough.  Followed by a sprinkle of blue cheese crumbles, a few fresh spinach leaves and my eggplant that has softened nicely.  Topped all of that with a little mozzarella.  I still had movement on the peel, but I was really concerned my zeal had gotten the best of me and this was too much weight for this delicate dough.

My fears were unfounded!  This was incredible!  I’m patting myself on my back (if you could see me- I’m skipping like a 4 year old girl).  I really want you to click on the image below so you can really get a glimpse of my heavenly dinner.

If you are keeping score, 1 pizza dough is only 404 calories.  This pizza is just a bit smaller than my dinner plate.  Depending on what you put on it and what you’ve done for the day, you can work this sucker off in no time!

**super side note… I weighed my flour this time.  and it only took 4 CUPS to get me to the 22 1/2z of flour I needed.  Cooking Spree wrote recently about weighing our scoops and how different each scoop can be.  It was a good reminder and I think I’ll weigh more often seeing how much of a difference it made.

Published by Lula Harp

I'm a mad scientist trying to find my tools.

9 thoughts on “I’m in Heaven…

  1. That is some sound advice. I do not bake without weighing my dry ingredients. EVER. I do not know a professional baker who does not use a scale. Americans are still holding on to the cup measurement and I assure your baking skills will advance quickly when you weigh you dry ingredients. My advice as a chef to anyone is to buy an internal read thermometer and a scale.


    1. I had never been a good baker because I don’t like measuring ingredients. Then when I began making soap and you have to be very specific it gave me a greater appreciation for the science of baking. and I also learned the importance of weighing and having a thermometer!


  2. I agree with Chef Connie, a scale is a must. Be sure to buy one that can toggle between ounces and grams. Accuracy in baking is important, scaling ingredients is the best way to go.

    This pizza looks great! terrific photo.


    1. This is a testament to my iphone. takes great pictures when my “real” camera isn’t at hand.

      and agreed- being able to measure both grams and ounces allows you greater ability to scale a recipe.


  3. That looks delicious. I’m literally drooling on the keyboard. Well, maybe not, but I need to try this pizza recipe.


  4. Well there you go my friend! All the searching, experimenting…finally, heaven! Happy for you. Have you had Crust’s Roni pizza? Yum. I think Crust is only in Michigan right now. Not sure. I don’t do pizza often as I am a low carb girl and well, that doesn’t quite fit in with the plan. However, I love it!!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: